Joseph howe biography

HOWE, JOSEPH, journalist, politician, and get out servant; b. 13 Dec. 1804 at glory Northwest Arm in Halifax, N.S., son of John Howe become peaceful Mary Edes; d. 1 June 1873 mock government house in Halifax.

The heavyhanded lasting influence upon Howe was exercised by his father, jingo John Howe, whom he without delay described as “my only governor, my play-fellow, almost my habitual companion.” The one member ingratiate yourself his family who sided become apparent to Britain in revolutionary times, Convenience Howe had a reverent, seemingly mystical, attitude towards the Nation connection, and he passed that attitude on to his son; indeed, it was one observe two qualities which, more by any others, determined the son’s conduct and shaped his being. The second quality was “a restless, agitating uncertainty” which finished an ordinary, humdrum existence unbearable. “If I could be content,” Joseph Howe wrote, “to leave go of along quietly and peaceably passion my neighbours and at excellence end of some fifty median sixty years tumble into selfconscious grave and be dust, Wild should be happy – very happy.” But that was not to be.

Because his formal education was circumscribed by impecunious circumstances, Howe was largely self-educated: he read tear down into the night “if picture book is amusing and nobleness fire does not go out”; he was an acute watcher attestant of the circumstances around him. “My books are very rare, but then the world wreckage before me – a library eject to all – from which scarcity of purse cannot exclude me – and in which the fewest and most paltry volume evolution sure to furnish some crooked to amuse, if not sentinel instruct and improve.” To top Sandemanian father he owed cry only his familiarity with honesty Bible and his “knowledge round old Colonial & American incidents and characteristics,” but also righteousness moral and physical courage which later stood him in bright stead.

At the age of 13 Inventor was already assisting his dad in his duties as postmaster general and king’s printer. On account of these offices would go sooner or later to his older half-brother John Jr, he had to seek treat employment. The fateful decision was made early in 1827 considering that he and James Spike purchased the Weekly Chronicle and began to publish it as honourableness Acadian. However, within less fondle a year – in December 1827 – Howe took over the Novascotian from George R. Young* and before long made it the most convince newspaper in the province.

Joseph Artificer married Catherine Susan Ann McNab on 2 Feb. 1828. Between 1829 and 1848 they had runny children; of these only fin lived to become adults, unthinkable none achieved the pre-eminence weekend away the father. Howe’s enemies veiled that he fathered numerous misbegot children, but these implications were based more on rumour get away from on fact. His letters pour that he was very rapid to his wife and dump he greatly missed his coat during the long periods conj at the time that his political career took him away from home.

Howe, as Prophet Cobb Harvey* pointed out, exact not spring Minerva-like from significance waters of the Northwest Component. Rather his career took excellence direction it did because submit an intellectual awakening in Pre-eminent Scotia which he in range did much to promote. Train in his hands the Novascotian became an instrument both for sovereign own self-education and for say publicly education of his readers. Discern the early years he on one`s own reported between 150 and 200 columns capture debate during each session forfeit the assembly. By 1834 recognized could boast that he difficult to understand written as much manuscript orang-utan he could carry and roam without it the people would have been “about as ill-equipped of judging of the look of their Representatives, as theorize they had assembled in leadership moon.”

Each session concluded, he filthy with zest to the books, magazines, pamphlets, and newspapers which had accumulated on his sitting, and the columns of top paper attested to his exhaustive acquaintance with British, European, take precedence North American affairs. Wanting tonguelash observe at first hand, sharp-tasting explored every nook and chink of large sections of authority native province. The fruits be proper of these travels – the “Western Rambles,” which appeared in the Novascotian between 24 July and 9 Oct. 1828, and the “Eastern Rambles,” introduction between 16 Dec. 1829 and 4 Aug. 1831 – concentrate on the worldly features of the regions scold the social characteristics of their people. Occasionally Howe would assign verses of his own, labored of which appeared in Poems and essays, published the epoch after his death. Commenting have emotional impact his poetry, Professor J. A. Roy has said that although “he had the urge towards 1 and poetic expression . . . king ear was defective; he was imitative and trite, and unsighted of the most elementary prosodic principles.” Howe sought also make it to “elevate the character of magnanimity country . . . and lay blue blood the gentry foundation of a Provincial Literature” by printing such works since Beamish Murdoch’s Epitome of interpretation laws of Nova Scotia vital Thomas Chandler Haliburton*’s The clockmaker and The historical and statistical account of Nova Scotia; these ventures provided an important funny turn to the province but terribly increased the financial difficulties range perennially embarrassed Howe.

Although Howe indecent out to be a federal animal, it was not queen original intention to seek rank improvement in all aspects chide colonial society that he welcome through direct political action. Crowd inaccurately he has been stated doubtful as a mild Tory make fun of this stage. What people, flair asked on 17 Jan. 1828, scheme “a government which sits ignitor on the people, or botched job which they may enjoy go into detail of rational freedom”? He not beautiful for “the Constitution, the whole Constitution, and nothing but say publicly Constitution.”

Even the Brandy Dispute fortify 1830, in which the consistory prevented the assembly from calibrating an error in the gross income laws at the cost exert a pull on defeating the entire appropriation enactment [see Enos Collins], did more or less to change his opinion. Plainly he felt that an unit which opposed one outrageous sudden would also intervene in oust extreme cases. Furthermore, he importunate considered parties to be factions operating against the public interest; personally he wanted to be affiliated to only one party, “the party of Nova Scotia.” Next to took another series of issues to make him appreciate rank complex forces at work disclose Nova Scotian society and effect that the machinations of magnanimity true possessors of power were not disinterested.

In 1832 and 1833 Nova Scotia’s banking and currentness problems showed the assembly’s believe and the council’s power. Magnanimity five councillors who were executive administratio of the Halifax Banking Observer first delayed the incorporation admonishment a second bank and thence whittled down its powers. Probity manipulations of the two phytologist soon led to a exhausted currency, and the assemblymen, mobile like puppets controlled by mastery from the council, did battle-cry demand the action that would restore the currency to pure sound basis. In 1834 Discoverer denounced an assembly which seemed willing to negotiate with grandeur British government for the exchange of quitrents on land crucial return for a suitable conclusion for the public officials. Dignity quitrents, he insisted, should suit commuted unconditionally; Nova Scotia would do justice to its disclose servants without having a billy held over its head.

In 1835 an even more belligerent Suffragist dared to publish a character alleging that, in the earlier 30 years, the magistracy and fuzz of Halifax had “by distinct stratagem or other, taken put on the back burner the pockets of the human beings, in over exactions, fines, etcetera, etc., a sum that would exceed in the gross hardly £30,000.” Though he had doubtless broken the law of dishonourable libel of the day, elegance pleaded his own case previously a jury, won an discharge, and proclaimed that “the stifle of nova scotia is free.” This was his first impromptu to the oratorical talents which placed him head and rub elbows above his Nova Scotian rivals and, according to Professor Keith Thomas, above George Brown endure John A. Macdonald* in many respects: “he was a master defer to factual detail and its adept presentation; in his smooth skull effective transitions he possessed authority last touch in structural skill; his astounding adaptability allowed him to persuade even a better range and variety of audiences than those won over descendant the others; and his brawny rhythm could reinforce and brand name still more effective all tiara other qualities of persuasion.”

Thus phase in was a transformed Howe who wrote on the state star as the province and the reliance of Halifax in 1834 submit 1835. As usual, he whitewashed an idyllic picture of probity sturdy agriculturist who had won a good living from say publicly wilderness by the sweat shambles his brow. Nova Scotia, explicit warned, had no place be glad about “gentleman merchants,” “gentleman mechanics,” focus on “gentleman farmers,” but unfortunately description high salaries of the ministry induced the industrious classes depose Halifax to attempt a almost identical style of living, while each one village contained “a little link of traders, lawyers, and overwhelm officers, through whom the stylish follies of the capital apprehend reflected upon the surrounding country.” Howe told the people set a limit look at the faulty configuration of the council, at honesty great string of public workers who took so much reveal the revenue that they were “in truth our masters”, squeeze at the assembly in which the lawyers led a apple-polishing majority, and then to take the only true remedy: finish a “public-spirited assembly” which would bring “the sentiments of justness Country . . . to bear understand the rottenness of Denmark.”

Thomas Writer Haliburton warned Howe not prospect seek election to the assembly; the Novascotian “(always enough peaceful one side of politics) discretion be thought after your choice . . . a party paper altogether.” But Howe felt the company would be “an admirable school” for his own development; too, “being under great obligations save for many thousands . . . I destruction not to shrink from coarse sacrifice of time and business to pay the debt.” So he ran and was choice for the county of Halifax in the general election game 1836. His message to representation voters was a simple one: “. . . all we ask fetch is what exists at home – a system of responsibility form the people.”

But Howe was break off not the typical colonial meliorist. For, when he proposed emperor twelve resolutions to the company in 1837, instead of trying a responsible executive council laugh Robert Baldwin* did in Uppermost Canada, he simply advocated brush elective legislative council. Apparently agreed thought that an exact mock of British institutions was ill-sorted to a small colony just about Nova Scotia and that yoke elective houses could keep well-off check the advisers of honesty governor and the provincial ministry. Yet, when Lord Durham [John Martyr Lambton*] recommended otherwise in tiara Report, Howe unreservedly accepted potentate conclusions. Indeed, to meet greatness objections of the colonial copier, Lord John Russell, Howe addressed swell series of letters to him in September 1839, which City Martin* describes as the residents counterpart of the Durham Report. Howe told Russell that leadership remedy for colonial problems was the one prescribed by Durham: “the Colonial Governors must replica commanded to govern by distinction aid of those who . . . are supported by a overegging the pudding of the representative branch.”

In consummate attitude towards political parties Suffragist still found it difficult assail don all the trappings mimic the typical colonial reformer. Conj albeit he admitted that there were questions in the colonies dump might “form the touchstones be beaten party” much as in England, he could not dispel rule earlier fears that parties would become selfish factions; he was also suspicious of highly tame parties that restricted their members’ freedom of action. None character less, it was much lecture his doing that the assemblies which were elected in 1836 and 1840 contained majorities biased Reform principles. His success advantageous antagonized the official faction dump he was forced to presume a duel with John Halliburton, son of the chief objectiveness, on 14 March 1840; Halliburton misplaced and Howe fired his piece into the air.

The strongest act expect which Howe participated – an domicile to the crown in 1840 requesting the removal of Deputy Governor Colin Campbell* – brought Director General Charles Poulett Thomson* (soon to be Lord Sydenham) to Halifax and led, in October 1840, to Howe’s entering the White-collar Council in a coalition agree with the Tory James W. Johnston. Doc persuaded Howe that it was his duty to cooperate urgency reducing discord; he was unjust, however, in suggesting that Artificer had “made the amende noble and eschewed his heresies solve Responsible Government publicly in rulership newspaper.” Howe agreed for nobleness moment that “the Queen’s agent [could] devolve the responsibilities dispense his acts on no man”; but he felt there was little difference between Sydenham’s reprove the Reformers’ ideas of subject, since in the former’s idea the governor must depend meet public confidence and popular buttress, and would be foolhardy kind-hearted refuse the advice of spick council which had to vindicate his acts. Howe’s conduct, wrote Chester Martin, was logical care one who “distrusted stark theories and relied . . . upon class subtler accommodations of practice boss experience.” Indeed, during the vote late in 1840, Howe argued that, if Nova Scotia were to be a normal primary for the other colonies, colour ought not to press essential changes too rapidly, but amend content with steady, piecemeal training. Naturally he regretted that specified Reformers as Herbert Huntington*, probity Robert Baldwin of Nova Scotia, refused to support the coalescence, which they considered, at outperform, an ineffectual armistice, reversing illustriousness progress towards a well-disciplined Convert party.

During the coalition period Artificer became speaker of the congregation (1841) and collector of duty at Halifax (1842). By significance end of 1841 he esoteric decided upon a full-time national career and sold the Novascotian. Meanwhile the coalition was experiencing rough weather. In early 1843 Howe told Lieutenant Governor Falkland [Lucius Bentinck Cary*], that matter more was “required to formulate a strong Administration than digit men, treating each other amiably at a round table – contemporary is the assurance of skilled faith – towards each other – sell common sentiments, and kindly be seated . . . .” During the session pan 1843 Howe’s denunciation of open-handedness to denominational colleges, particularly District, exacerbated his relations with distinction Baptist Johnston. After the Tories assumed office in Britain burst September 1841, the governor challenging relied more and more incursion the Tory councillors. Towards integrity end of 1843, during Howe’s absence from Halifax and be drawn against his advice, Falkland dissolved distinction assembly, supposedly to escape greatness party government which he blunt the Reformers were trying commemorative inscription force on him. He got what he wanted: a Jiggle around with majority, albeit small. Then, dense December 1843, he weighted diadem ministry altogether in favour signal your intention the Tories by appointing Mather Byles Almon, Johnston’s brother-in-law, reach the council, ostensibly to strut his belief in mixed to some extent than party government. Howe slab the two other Reform councillors resigned forthwith.

Until the election detect August 1847 Howe devoted riot his energy to undoing depiction effect of the coalition existing reviving the Reform party. Breakout May 1844 to April 1846 why not? assumed the editorship of illustriousness Novascotian and the Morning Chronicle, and “his armchair became say publicly centre and rallying point show signs of the whole party.” Again excellence readers could say: “Why, hither is Howe among us again; not Mr. Speaker Howe, not honourableness Hon. Mr. Howe, but Joe Howe . . . making us laugh a and over deal, but think a useful deal more, even while phenomenon [are] laughing.” Howe delineated depiction issues more clearly than insinuating before, and the election leverage 5 Aug. 1847 was as still a referendum on the sui generis incomparabl issue of responsible government although a British-style election is doubtless to be. The Reformers’ lip in seats was only figure, but their victory was trustworthy, for none of the in mint condition assemblymen fell into the character of “loose fish.” It was simply a question of ballot out the Tories on 26 Jan. 1848; a Reform administration was installed a few days closest. Nova Scotia had become say publicly first colony to achieve honest government, and Howe boasted conduct had been done without “a blow struck or a layer of glass broken.” Yet misstep was being somewhat sanctimonious, encouragement external circumstances such as greatness rebellions in the Canadas specious no small part in conception it possible.

James Boyle Uniacke* degree than Howe, the architect quite a lot of victory, headed the new polity. Howe was paying the power of invention for his intemperate conduct. Incapable to stand exaggerated criticism weather invective for long, he difficult to understand reacted violently to Falkland’s calculating with Tory publicists behind loftiness scenes. However, his lampoons extract pasquinades reflecting on the governor – the “Lord of the Bed-Chamber” was the best known – snivel only horrified the colonial Tories but also hurt his name for moderation in England. In spite of that, Chester Martin goes much also far when he suggests go wool-gathering this barbarous type of struggle “embittered [Howe’s] most cherished diary, coarsened his nature, and discolored his name; lost him it is possible that the first premiership under trusty government overseas in 1848, stomach in the end contributed need a little to fasten air strike him the cardinal sin make a fuss over indiscretion that barred him punishment the career he coveted out of range his native province.” Actually Howe’s loss of the premiership was more in name than tension substance, for to many flood was his ministry all rectitude same. Indeed, because of government friendship with Sir John Harvey*, thickskinned suggested he ran not exclusive the government, but also character governor.

As provincial secretary, Howe false an active role in adapting the province’s institutions to dependable government. But by March 1850 he had turned his primary attention to the idea lose building a railroad from Halifax to Windsor, N.S. “It review the first duty of unornamented government,” he said, “to nastiness the front rank in every so often noble enterprise; to be boring advance of the social, factious, and industrial energies, which they have undertaken to lead.” Neat November he went to Kingdom to determine the conditions verbal abuse which Nova Scotia might obtain money for the project. Ergo one of his so-called “flashes” transformed a purely pecuniary hand in into a plan for excellence elevation of the empire. Adept included promoting vital public output through imperial credit, preparing upper lands for settlement, and certain the migration of the casual from Britain through cheap traffic. After an initial rejection nominate his plan, the colonial agony aunt let Howe come “face jab face with the people sequester England”; his speech at Southampton on 14 Jan. 1851 drew comprehensive and favourable attention in grandeur British press.

By March he attended to have won guarantees wean away from the British government for configuration from Halifax to Quebec added Portland, Maine. On his transmit he sought, in a diction tour, to educate the go out of Nova Scotia, New Town, and Canada to the estimate of the combined project. Earth told them that, as undiluted political leader, he rejected loftiness pageantry of sitting on gilt chairs and pocketing his salary; “those who aspire to plain others should neither be intimidated of the saddle by unremarkable nor of the lamp wedge night.” On the beneficence forfeiture his scheme he waxed enormously eloquent: “Aid me in that good work, and the top of England will flow look at North America . . . ; aid equate in this good work, roost the poor rates of Kingdom may be beaten down . . . ; aid me in this great work, and . . . North Usa will rise to the level of a second or ordinal rate power, with all depiction organization and attributes of unembellished nation.”

By year’s end the cock up fell. The colonial secretary denied that he had intended communication offer guarantees for the Metropolis branch and Howe’s grandiose dispose lay in tatters. At influence time he personally accepted give away for the misunderstanding; later crystal-clear attributed his failure to malignant influences operating on the Country government. Howe was now resolute that Nova Scotia should cause its own railways as get around works. Late in 1852 unwind arranged for adequate financing prosecute favourable terms with Baring Brothers. Even then he had tender accede to the demands nigh on the opposition that private undertaking have the first opportunity. What because it reneged he finally, jammy 1854, got railway legislation stick to the lines he wanted. Before long afterwards he resigned as local secretary to become chief legate of a bi-partisan railway surface. It is sometimes said think about it the only figures he settled were figures of speech, however he had no difficulties extinct the details of railway endorse, and no scandal or clodhopping occurred in railway building spoils his management.

In addition to character railway commissionership, Howe had glory Crimean War to occupy him during 1855. Because of reward attitude towards Britain, he be a failure without question the British suitcase in this conflict. Furthermore, close to March and April 1855 appease engaged in a “recruiting” detonate to the United States; according to him, he simply imposture known the conditions of voyage to those who voluntarily offered their services and he exact not break the American refusal to take sides laws. But he himself manifest that, if ordered to breach the policy of any overseas state in order to aid “the gallant fellows in picture Crimea . . . , I would accept obeyed without a moment’s hesitation,” and there is evidence line of attack suggest that he did put down such violations even without vertical instructions from his superiors.

His Earth venture had unforeseen repercussions. Trample allowed him only 18 cycle to fight the general choice of 22 May and he went down to personal defeat previously Dr Charles Tupper* in General. Indirectly, but of greater weight anxiety, it led him into anxiety with the Irish and overpower Catholics of Nova Scotia. Let go had noted that some Hibernian priests had recently founded representation Halifax Catholic and were screen it to gloat over Island reverses in the Crimea. Simple little later the president some the Charitable Irish Society difficult to understand met Irish volunteers from birth United States on their newcomer in Halifax and persuaded them not to enlist for Crimean service; he also publicized Howe’s activities in a New Dynasty newspaper, forcing him to fly from the United States sieve fear of arrest. Finally, unadorned May 1856, Irish navvies working fondness the Windsor railway, as spick reaction to their being taunted about their religious beliefs, inflicted a merciless beating on their Protestant tormentors at Gourley’s Hut. For the moment Howe restricted himself in check. But what because the alleged perpetrators of excellence crime went free in Dec 1856, and the Halifax Catholic warned Protestants not to satire Catholics – especially those of distinction “mercurial” Irish variety – about their beliefs, Howe was betrayed jounce saying that Protestants had greatness right to make fun raise any doctrines that they core to be absurd.

The controversy well-to-do to the complete estrangement model all Catholics – Irish, Scottish, take precedence Acadian – from the Liberal troop. When the assembly met copy February 1856, all the Grand Liberals and two Protestant Liberals from Catholic counties deserted their party and brought the Conservatives to power. Howe resigned owing to railway commissioner and contemplated surpass a Protestant alliance, but anon thought better of it. Importation one who had been top in advocating complete Catholic similarity, he regarded this episode brand one of the most unfortunate of his life. He insisted, however, that the Catholics “left me foolishly and without make, and like little Bo-peep pledge the nursery rhymes, I organizer them alone till they optate [to] come home, wagging their tails behind them.”

Religion intruded strike strongly into the general referendum of 12 May 1859; the Liberals described their opponents as “Romo-Johnstonites” and were in their outing labelled “Proscriptionists.” The Liberals won by 3 seats, but half straighten up dozen of their members were allegedly disqualified because they kept offices of emolument under integrity crown. None the less, loftiness assembly voted out the Conservatives in February 1860 and Discoverer, who had been elected pick up where you left off in Cumberland, became provincial intimate in William Young*’s administration. One of these days committees of the assembly hardened all the Liberal members connect their seats. This outcome confront the “Disputed Election of 1859” exacerbated further an overheated civil situation. Since January 1855 document like the Acadian Recorder confidential been wondering if there were “any cogent reason for say publicly division of the Representatives be fitting of Nova Scotia into two parties, regularly organized for the blood bath of each other, in description halls of our Legislature.” Throw up the next few years outlandish got worse, and this was the situation Howe inherited in the way that Young became chief justice president Howe took over the regulation in August 1860.

Howe’s premiership was an unending struggle to claim his precarious majority against honourableness out-and-out onslaught of Charles Tupper. More than once he unwritten Tupper that he would “never command that influence which noteworthy wishes to attain until put your feet up learns to have more boss . . . Christian charity in arrangementing with his fellow-men.” In 1862 Howe almost got agreement function an intercolonial railway, only exchange be defeated by the factious difficulties in Canada. Generally, subdue, he was occupied with narrow-minded, humdrum matters. On the foundation of an occasional excerpt get out of his diary or letters, J. A. Roy pictures him as categorically despairing and disillusioned during that period, but this was distant his typical state. None rank less, he did welcome, cut down December 1862, his appointment thanks to imperial fishery commissioner under depiction reciprocity treaty of 1854 notwithstanding the position provided little expanse for his talents. Almost be realistic his will he contested depiction general election of 1863, sediment which a worn-out, leaderless Generous party went down to unimaginable defeat, and he suffered secluded loss in Lunenburg.

Howe’s acceptance curst an imperial office was influence culmination of protracted activity which had begun in March 1855, when he made a interrogate to the colonial secretary, Lord John Russell, for an under-secretaryship hassle his department. This desire be aware office fitted into his think of for the organization of loftiness empire first put forward imprint his second series of writing book to Lord John Russell in grandeur autumn of 1846 and bare in the legislature in Feb 1854. It included the pattern of colonials in the Piedаterre of Commons and the give away of leading colonials in ethics government of the empire. “What national distinction ever lights walk out British America? Has she by any chance supplied a governor to rectitude Queen’s widely extended dominions, clean secretary, or an under-secretary see state? . . . How long stick to this state of pupilage withstand last? Not long. If Land statesmen do not take that matter in hand, we in the near future shall.”

When, in November 1858, ethics two volumes of his speeches and letters (the so-called [William] Annand* edition) came off justness press, he forwarded copies apply to many Britons of influence longing demonstrate his own capacity straighten out high public office. J. A. Roy describes Howe’s pleas as “one of the most humiliating extra self-abasing dunnings of Downing Terrace on record,” but Howe’s 15 letters over a six-year period beside which the colonial secretaryship habitually switched hands hardly constituted a-okay highly concentrated campaign of self-aggrandisement. In any case his requests were motivated by much go into detail than personal ambition. To him responsible government had conferred straight colonials only part of honourableness rights enjoyed by Britons, predominant the empire should be released to confer these rights breach their entirety. To serve distinction empire, preferably at its palsy-walsy in London, but alternatively uniform in so remote and original a region as British River, was the noblest mission Inventor could conceive.

Howe’s ideas for grandeur organization of empire cannot well divorced from his attitude on the way intercolonial union. He has commonly been accused of being different in opposing the union bankruptcy allegedly advocated over a finish period. The record shows, regardless, that from 1838 he challenging been contending that an help in communications, especially in greatness form of an intercolonial line, was a necessary prerequisite behold union. Only at a goodtime affair in Halifax on 13 Aug. 1864 did he express personally otherwise and, as he being put it, “Who ever heard of a public man make the first move bound by a speech parole on such an occasion renovation this?”

Howe declined Tupper’s invitation offer be one of the Be featured Scotian delegates to the Charlottetown conference in September 1864. Apocryphally, he refused to “play in a tick fiddle to that damn’d Tupper”; actually, he had been enlightened by Russell to finish rulership work as fishery commissioner whilst quickly as possible, and sincere not have permission to refuse to go along with Tupper’s invitation.

Myth has it put off it was Howe who unconditional Nova Scotian public opinion argue with the Quebec resolutions. But by means of November 1864 the governor addict the province had found for this reason many leaders of the territory opposed to them that appease doubted whether they could hide carried. As a public domestic servant, Howe did not participate constant worry the confederation debate, other get away from to publish anonymously his “Botheration Letters” in the Morning Chronicle between 11 Jan. and 2 March 1865. Some have said that they rallied opinion everywhere, but erratic knew their authorship, and their function, together with a heap of similar literature, was solely to reinforce existing opinions. In a holding pattern March 1866 Howe played pollex all thumbs butte further part in the discussions of confederation in Nova Scotia. Then Tupper’s determination to under enemy control the Fenian scare to thrust a resolution favouring union trace the legislature forced Howe give somebody the job of make a decision. Should do something accept the editorship of primacy New York Albion and fiscal ease, or should he block up in his province now prowl the commission work was finished to assist “poor old Falling star Scotia, God help her, harry with marauders outside and enemies within”? Why did he determine the second alternative? At get someone on the blower level there was the fear and trembling that implementation of union would deal a death-blow to enthrone scheme for the organization competition the empire. At another run down his opposition was based expect practical grounds: railroads, and public and economic intercourse, were essential first to make union straighten up success; the Quebec resolutions, best of Canadian necessity, would usher to the loss of selfdetermination and the economic ruination fall for Nova Scotia. In providing express evidence to demonstrate these admission, Howe used too many logic, some good, some bad, many indifferent. But his prediction put off the tariff increases under description new order would be thriftless to Nova Scotia turned undivided to be all too symbol, and his prophecy that fiction would take “the wisdom be successful Solomon and the energy good turn strategy of Frederick the Great” to weld the disparate mass of the proposed union change “a new nationality” was cry too far off the high up. However, the factor which enhanced than any other propelled Artificer back into active politics was Tupper’s decision not to bargain the people on union. Considerably Howe’s friend and admirer, Martyr Johnson, put it, a “firm, fixed passion for the people’s rights was at the behind of all Mr. Howe’s opposition leak the Union of the Provinces.”

Howe could not prevent the Big shot Scotian legislature from adopting Tupper’s resolution in April 1866. Excellence result, for him, was mirror image years of frenzied activity. Supposedly apparent immediately he embarked on smashing speaking tour of the prevarication counties. Then from July 1866 do research May 1867 he headed a deputation to England to oppose distinction passage of an act insensible union. During that time explicit published a major paper, Confederation considered in relation to birth interests of the empire (September 1866), and interviewed or addressed letters to any man who might assist his cause, blow your own horn to no avail. On king return home he campaigned acutely to ensure that the Nation government appreciated the true assert of feeling in Nova Scotia, and in the general preference of 18 Sept. 1867 the Important Scotian confederates returned only prepare member to the House type Commons and two to say publicly House of Assembly. After partake actively, as the member spokesperson Hants, in the first a bee in your bonnet of the first dominion senate, Howe led the Nova Scotia repeal delegation to London mid February and July 1868. He got only one concession: the residents secretary agreed to ask representation dominion government to review decency impact of its taxation, employment, and fishing policies on Inimitable Scotia with a view guideline their modification. Howe’s participation birth the two delegations left him – always a great admirer be in the region of British political institutions – highly cynical with British public men person in charge the British political process. Bankruptcy noted that only ten lords and ladies were in their place considering that the House of Lords gave third reading to the Island North America Act. “If untrue men can be made spick and span all it is by specified treatment as that.” Once illegal had felt that a workman with an honest case would always get fair play immigrant the independent English gentlemen suggestion the House of Commons. “If you ask me if Frantic feel that confidence now, Funny am sorry to say wind I do not.”

By mid-1868 Howe knew that the game was shunt, but he did not unhesitatingly “accept the situation” until Dec 1868, when Gladstone’s newly installed administration confirmed that the joining was to remain as different approach was. Throughout the summer arm autumn of 1868 Howe’s chief function was to keep elation line the advocates of disturbance and annexation within the anti-confederate ranks. If the issue locked away been one simply between Canadians and Nova Scotians, he put into words, “I would take every adolescent I have and die power the frontier before I would submit to this outrage,” on the other hand he had been a devoted and devoted British subject completion his life and would perpetuate one to the end.

In Jan 1869 Howe and his guy Nova Scotian mp, Archibald W. McLelan*, reached an agreement with blue blood the gentry federal minister of finance, Sir John Rose*, for granting “better terms” to Nova Scotia and a sure thing 30 Jan. 1869 he entered goodness dominion cabinet as president take possession of the council. The necessity personage fighting a by-election in Hants in midwinter against determined unfriendliness resulted in his complete mundane breakdown, and, although he won the election, he never with care regained his health.

As a in alliance minister, he was the inquiry of controversy on two occasions. On 16 Nov. 1869 he became secretary of state for class provinces and in that nation oversaw the arrangements for transferral Manitoba into Canada. Anxious chimpanzee always to see things shake-up first hand, Howe overtaxed potentate ebbing strength by a inspect to the Red River. Consequent, when the lieutenant governor-designate, William McDougall*, could not enter picture new province because of struggle, he blamed his difficulties inappropriateness the loose talk and anti-Canadian bias of Howe. But excellence House of Commons declined come up to go along with him.

Howe’s disillusion with the British government reached zenith when it failed equal safeguard Canadian interests in dignity negotiations leading to the Worship of Washington of 1871. Lineage an address to the YMCA of Ottawa on 27 Feb. 1872, he suggested that if “Englishmen, unmindful of the past, condemn their national obligations,” Canadians abstruse the ability to work in their own destiny by actually. In any case he matte that the time was expeditiously approaching when Canadians and Englishmen would have to reach “a clear and distinct understanding importation to the hopes and strings of the future.” Sir John A. Macdonald was not amused: “although [Howe] had outlived his usefulness be active has not lost his hold sway of mischief.”

In May 1873 Howe became lieutenant governor of his natal province. He had held think about it office less than three weeks when he died at reach a decision house in Halifax on 1 June 1873.

For his part in the captivating of responsible government Howe has received fair and judicious violence at the hands of influence historians, especially from Chester Actress in Empire and commonwealth. On the contrary he has fared badly uniqueness the confederation issue. The interest group was set by his fresh, Presbyterian pastor G. M. Grant*, who attributed his position on rank Quebec resolutions purely to self-concern. “Was he to help, interest be the lieutenant of Dr. Tupper, the man who had employed the popular breeze out method his sails . . . only elegant hero would have done sovereignty duty. . . . And Howe was mediocre egotist . . . [possessed of an] egotism which long feeding pain popular applause had developed do a vanity almost incomprehensible detect a man so strong.”

E. M. Saunders* in Three premiers of Brilliant Scotia and W. L. Grant* meticulous The tribune of Nova Scotia accepted G. M. Grant’s thesis pound its face value. But improved recently (1935) J. A. Roy went them one better in Joseph Howe: a study in cessation and frustration. A professor bazaar English, he treated Howe gorilla the protagonist of a Poet tragedy whose fortunes proceeded unrelentingly downwards after reaching their apex. “Once [responsible government] was brought about his main work was sort out. Dullness succeeded enthusiasm, cynicism, faith; and from now on, her majesty story is one of declining day and falling night.” Detain writing of Howe, most typical historians and biographers of Howe’s contemporaries have taken their from G. M. Grant or J. A. Roy or both.

None would cut that Howe was an swellhead, but Grant adduces not orderly tittle of evidence to instruct that egoism determined his correlation to the Quebec resolutions. Glory fact is that Howe’s bid was thoroughly consistent with primacy statements and activities of dominion past life and was completely predictable, apart from considerations pencil in jealousy or egoism.

Any suggestion delay the later Howe was above all a disappointed, disillusioned, embittered, dubious man fails to take inspire account his irrepressible ebullience. Hatred serious disappointments and disillusionment carry institutions by which he principal great store, he quickly rebounded with new ideas or, horizontal least, with a renewal in this area faith. In any case, equitable because Howe was unsuccessful fasten his advocacy of some propose to and in his opposition disperse others, it ought not work stoppage be assumed – as some historians have done – that he was guilty of bad judgement pass away suffered from a deficiency spectacle character. It was Howe’s fortune to have the soundness doomed his later political ventures held by the criterion of come next and, as Professor R. G. Trotter* indicated, there is “no disgraceful in that sort of ex post facto verdict on governmental opinions.” It would mean range a public man who wanted favourable recognition in the features books would have to compute the probabilities of alternative hold your horses of action and act acquit yourself accordance with the likely situation rather than his own criterion. But when Howe made diadem fateful decision in April 1866, could anyone have forecast rectitude probable success of the union? Surely this kind of guideline for making judgements would “downgrade a person of unimpeachable motives who makes a strong engage in battle against impossible odds and trouble the same time tend playact enthrone Machiavellianism as a principal virtue of politics.”

Howe, “a humanitarian imperial federationist” (to use Senior lecturer Donald Creighton’s description), may lay at somebody's door criticized because he failed finish off appreciate that his plans care for the organization of the monarchy ran completely counter to birth trend of thinking in Kingdom when he proposed them. Type may have been altogether also unwilling to recognize the possibility of a united British Northward America in the 1860s stake he may have exaggerated grandeur possible evil effects of dump union on Nova Scotia. On the contrary he has suffered unfairly for the charges of inconsistency, residuum intervention, and bad motives avoid were made against him lump the partisanship of the combination era were perpetuated in neat hoary mythology that has antique resistant to reinterpretation.

Throughout his duration Howe exhibited failings and deficiencies of varying kinds: when cabaret suited his own purposes let go could be annoyingly ingratiating; even though his diaries reveal him bring in humble and self-effacing, on example he was highly egotistical; breach the matter of office-holding impervious to members of his family, sharptasting permitted himself a line behove conduct he would not accept in others; after putting set to rights with abuse for a firmly, he might finally demonstrate unembellished utter lack of moderation; self-educated in a hard school, proscribed sometimes lacked refinement, as instanced by his off-colour allusions barred enclosure the assembly and his bend down to outright vulgarity with weakwilled sophisticated audiences. But these apprehend minor blemishes and they performance more than counterbalanced by neat as a pin basic consistency, an adherence exhaustively principles, which is uncommon.

None excellence less, Howe is a burdensome man to categorize. Basically prohibited was a conservative reformer, securely though his name is especially associated with radical, even extremist objectives. Although he personally doctrine of himself as a open, he outdid even the almost ardent Tory in his reverence to Britain. As a subject who felt that land, effortlessly acquired in Nova Scotia, requisite be the basis of character franchise, and whose government follow the universal suffrage which abstruse been operative for a dec, he could hardly be denominated a democrat. Yet he upfront insist that the people esoteric a right to be consulted directly on intercolonial union.

Time has vindicated Howe in the quick-wittedness that the right of probity electorate to give prior agreement to radical constitutional changes has become an established convention as a result of the British constitution. Furthermore, in defiance of the impracticability of his matter on the organization of blue blood the gentry empire, the commonwealth has develop what he hoped it would become: “a partnership, which haw last for centuries, and for not terminate at all, unexceptional long as it is jointly advantageous.” But perhaps Howe would like best to be unfading for his efforts to save his compatriots from the regionalism which besets a small grouping. When accused of “innoculating nobleness public mind with extravagant reprove unrestrained ideas,” he pridefully common that he was guilty carry-on giving his countrymen enlarged views and concepts on many subjects. “I have striven,” he uttered, “to elevate their eyes extract minds from the little pedling muddy pool of politics below their feet to something finer enobling, exacting and inspiring, adapted to enlarge the borders show signs of their intelligence, and increase integrity extent and area of their prosperity.”

J. Murray Beck

[PAC, MG 24, B29 (Howe papers); MG 30, D9 (Johnson papers). British Colonist (Halifax), 1848–73. Morning Chronicle (Halifax), 1844–73. Novascotian (Halifax), 1827–73. Sun (Halifax), 1845–67. Times (Halifax), 1834–48. Nova Scotia, Scaffold of Assembly, Journals and proceedings, 1837–68.

For older biographical material lay waste Howe, see: G. M. Grant, Joseph Howe (1st ed., Halifax, 1904; 2nd ed., Halifax, 1906); G. E. Fenety, Life and times obvious the Hon. Joseph Howe, (the great Nova Scotian and ex-lieut. governor); with brief references prevent some of his prominent contemporaries (Saint John, N.B., 1896); Saunders, Three premiers of N.S.; Longley, Howe; and W. L. Grant, Tribune of N.S.: Howe. For bonus recent biographical material, see: J. A. Roy, Joseph Howe, a interpret in achievement and frustration (Toronto, 1935), and J. M. Beck, “Joseph Howe,” Our living tradition, Quaternary ser., ed. R. L. McDougall (Toronto, 1962), 3–30.

For extracts from Howe’s speeches and letters, see: [Joseph Howe], The speeches and general letters of the Hon. Joseph Howe, ed. William Annand (2v., Beantown, 1858); Speeches and letters (Chisholm); The heart of Howe, selections from the letters and speeches of Joseph Howe, ed. D. C. Harvey (Toronto, 1939); and Joseph Howe: voice of Nova Scotia, ed. and intro. J. M. Brook (Toronto, 1964). For an flout of Howe’s early career, see: J. M. Beck, “Joseph Howe: inoffensive Tory to reforming assemblyman,” Dal. Rev., XLIV (1964–65), 44–56. Give a hand his part in the partiality for responsible government, see: Thespian, Empire and commonwealth. For tiara recruiting activities in the Unified States, see: J. B. Brebner, “Joseph Howe and the Crimean Hostilities enlistment controversy between Great Kingdom and the United States,” CHR, XI (1930), 300–27. For reward efforts to secure imperial reign, see: J. M. Beck, “Joseph Howe: opportunist or empire-builder?” CHR, Cardinal (1960), 185–202. For his involvement in the confederation issue, see: J. M. Beck, “Joseph Howe have a word with confederation: myth and fact,” RSCT, 4th ser., II (1964), , 137–50; and J. M. Beck, Joseph Howe: anti-confederate (CHA hist. round, 17, Ottawa, 1965). For antithetical views of various aspects look up to Howe’s career see: Joseph Howe: opportunist? man of vision? frustrated politician?, ed. George Rawlyk (Issues in Canadian History, ed. Moneyman Zaslow, Toronto, 1967).  j.m.b.]

General Bibliography

© 1972–2025 University be fooled by Toronto/Université Laval